NewProvision launches Scope Agent, now generally availableRead the announcement →
Provision

How Westmark cut drawing review from 3 days to 3 hours with Provision

The Challenge

More bids than the team could scope

Westmark Construction is a mid sized general contractor in Nanaimo, British Columbia. Scoping was not the hard part. The problem was who had to do it. It took an experienced person to write a scope and then check it, and those people were needed everywhere else.

Four days to read it

Reading a public tender and splitting the work out by trade took three to four days. The same people were being pulled onto other jobs while it ran.

Too few could do it

Only a handful of the team could finish a scope and then check it. Everything else waited on them.

Some buried, some idle

Some people were running at 150 percent while others sat nearer 80. At the top of that range you start losing people.

No time for the bid

Quantity takeoffs, trade calls, bid strategy and the executive review all fought over whatever time was left.

On what the company is trying to fix:

“A big thing we are focusing on is utilization rate. Are there some people running at 150%, some people running at 80%? How can we level that off so that we are not running into burnout?”

— Drew Fisher, Preconstruction Manager, Westmark Construction

The Solution

Why Westmark tested Scope Agent

Westmark wanted to see it on a real job first. They ran it on a live bid and checked it against their own times.

Run on a live public tender. Scope Agent went through an open bid Westmark was actually pricing, not a sample set.
Measured against their own times. The before and after are Westmark’s own numbers for the same work.
The estimator still decides. Scope Agent takes the first pass through the documents. The estimator writes the final scope and sets the price.

Westmark’s New Process

What came back before anyone opened the drawings

Read the set and split it by trade. Scope Agent took the drawings and the specification and worked out which trade each item belonged to.
Said where the scope was missing. Where nothing covered a piece of work, or two trades both looked responsible for it, Scope Agent flagged it and suggested wording to close the gap.
Easy to see what looked wrong. Colour coded tables meant an estimator could run down a package and pick out anything out of place.
Some of the mistakes were not mistakes. A few items that looked like the agent getting it wrong turned out to be real problems in the drawings. Those normally only get caught when an experienced estimator spots something odd across several drawing sets.
Somebody still checks it. Westmark reads the output either way. The time saving is what is left after that check.

Their ROI

What the trial measured

A large concrete slab and formwork on a waterfront site

What Westmark has seen:

Three days down to two or three hours. That is the first pass through the drawings and the specification, with the human check already counted in.
A day and a half to executive review. The trade scope package was ready for executive review in about a day and a half, against the usual three to four days.
The saving is bigger than the cost. ConstructIQ found the time saved was worth more than what Scope Agent costs.
25 to 30 percent more capacity, on their own numbers. ConstructIQ ran Westmark’s bid volumes and win ratios and put the gain at roughly five to six more project wins a year. That is a planning estimate, not a result Westmark has banked.
The hours went back into the bid. Talking to trades, building out the scope, checking quantities, bid strategy and the executive review.

On what changed for the person doing the review:

“From my typical three days of drawing review, it is now going to take two or three hours, even still including human review.”

— Levi Alonso, Preconstruction Coordinator, Westmark Construction

ConstructIQ Advisory put Westmark and Provision in touch. Westmark tested Provision for four weeks on two projects.

See how pre-construction teams are boosting win rates and profits with Provision

Book a Demo
$100 billion in project value reviewed with Provision
Get through pursuits 2x faster